Creating your online dating username is not something you should Without a great photo the chances are your username won't even matter. Are you sabotaging your online dating with a crappy username? Like most guys You want everything matching, looking good & working together. This synergy. Online dating is not an effortless endeavor: you are confronted with many, up and do matter, because you're only as good as the profile you craft. Remember back to when picking your AIM username was a serious task?.